As parents, one of the most common frustrations we face is feeling like our children "won’t listen." This feeling can be overwhelming and disheartening, especially when we find ourselves in situations where our repeated commands such as "Don’t do that," "Stop," or "No" seem to fall on deaf ears. Many parents find themselves in a cycle of issuing commands, hoping that by simply stating what not to do, they can effectively curb undesirable behavior. However, research shows that focusing on what not to do can lead to increased frustration and confusion for both you and your child (Gordon, 2000). Instead of merely prohibiting certain actions, teaching children what to do by giving clear, positive directions can significantly improve compliance and reduce the likelihood of challenging behaviors. When we reframe our instructions to tell children what behaviors are expected, we set them up for success and create a more harmonious environment for both parties.
The Power of Positive Directions
The way we communicate with our children plays a pivotal role in shaping their behavior. Children often respond more effectively to instructions that clearly outline the desired action, rather than vague or negative commands that leave them guessing. Positive directions are not only clearer for children, but they also empower them by providing concrete steps to follow. For example, instead of telling a child, “Don’t run,” consider saying, “Walk inside.” This simple yet impactful change in phrasing encourages the behavior you want to see and is easier for the child to understand, making it more likely that they will follow through with the instruction. By focusing on positive language, we create an atmosphere where children are more inclined to listen and act accordingly.
Tips for Giving Positive Directions
The BEDIRECT acronym is a tool used in Parent-Child Interaction Therapy (PCIT) to help parents effectively communicate and interact with their children. Each letter in the acronym represents a specific strategy or principle that enhances parent-child interactions. Here’s a breakdown of the BEDIRECT components:
B - Behavior Description: Describe the child's behavior objectively without judgment. This helps the child understand what they are doing right or wrong.
E - Effective Praise: Offer specific and genuine praise for positive behaviors. This reinforces good behavior and encourages its repetition.
D - Direct Commands: Give clear and concise commands to the child. This helps the child understand what is expected of them.
I - Ignoring: Ignore minor misbehaviors that are not harmful. This reduces attention-seeking behaviors by not rewarding them with attention.
R - Reflection: Reflect on what the child is saying or doing. This shows the child that you are listening and valuing their thoughts and feelings.
E - Enthusiasm: Use an enthusiastic tone and engage actively with the child. This makes interactions more enjoyable and encourages positive engagement.
C - Consistency: Be consistent in responses and expectations. This helps the child understand the rules and what is expected of them.
T - Time-Out (if necessary): Implement time-out as a consequence for serious misbehavior, allowing the child to calm down and reflect.
By utilizing the BEDIRECT strategies, parents can foster more positive and effective interaction with their children, promoting better behavior and enhancing the parent-child relationship.
Examples of Positive Directions
Here are a few examples that can help reshape your approach to parenting and enhance communication with your child:
Instead of saying, “Stop yelling,” try “Use your inside voice.” This clearly communicates the expectation while promoting a more appropriate behavior.
Instead of saying, “Don’t throw toys,” say, “Toys stay on the floor.” This directs the child to the correct action without confusion.
Instead of “Stop bothering your sister,” say, “You can ask for a turn.” This not only addresses the behavior but also teaches a valuable social skill.
When you shift your approach to stating what your child can do, you make your expectations much clearer, and children are more likely to comply. This strategy also helps reduce the power struggles that can occur when children don’t understand what is being asked of them, fostering a more cooperative and understanding relationship.
The Research Behind Positive Directions
Research underscores the importance of positive communication in promoting healthy parent-child relationships. Positive directions are more likely to lead to compliance and less likely to result in defiance or confusion (Gordon, 2000). By providing children with explicit instructions about what they should do, parents not only reduce conflict but also foster an environment where children feel more confident and capable. In a study conducted by the National Center for Pyramid Model Innovations, it was found that children who received clear, positive directions were more likely to exhibit the desired behavior and were less likely to engage in challenging behavior (National Center for Pyramid Model Innovations, 2020). This highlights the importance of framing instructions in a way that promotes understanding and cooperation, rather than focusing solely on prohibitions.
Context: Why Positive Directions Matter
We often hear from parents who are concerned that their children just “won’t listen.” It's easy to fall into the habit of repeatedly saying "no" or "stop," especially when dealing with challenging behaviors that arise in daily life. However, these phrases can be vague and confusing. Children might not know exactly what behavior is being asked of them. For instance, saying “no running” doesn’t tell the child what they should do instead. A clearer direction, such as “Please walk inside,” not only communicates the expected behavior but also helps the child focus on positive actions that contribute to a more peaceful environment.
When children engage in difficult behaviors, it can be tempting to focus solely on stopping those behaviors. But positive directions not only prevent undesirable actions but also actively teach children the alternative behaviors you want them to adopt. This approach reduces frustration for both parents and children and supports children’s growth and development, ultimately leading to a more fulfilling and constructive parent-child relationship.
Conclusion: The Importance of Positive Communication
By shifting to positively stated directions, parents can significantly reduce behavioral challenges and promote healthier interactions with their children. Clear, positive instructions not only help children understand what is expected but also set them up for success. With practice, you will notice that your child begins to respond more effectively, reducing frustration on both sides. So next time you find yourself about to say "no" or "stop," pause and think about what you want your child to do instead. With consistent use of positive directions, you’ll be on your way to fostering a more cooperative and peaceful environment in your home.
References
Gordon, T. (2000). Parent effectiveness training: The proven program for raising responsible children. Three Rivers Press.
National Center for Pyramid Model Innovations. (2020). Positive behavior support in early childhood: Evidence-based strategies. ChallengingBehavior.org.
Comments